image description image description

LATEST DIALOGUES Does ‘free will’ Arise From Brain Noise?

“Man can do what he wills, but he cannot will what he wills.” 
Arthur Schopenhauer


photo: Marco Redaelli


“Is free will an illusion?” is a question that has plagued philosophers and scientists for thousands of years.

Now, a new study suggests that free will may arise from random fluctuations in the brain’s background electrical noise, and that this activity occurs almost a second before people consciously decide to do something.

Though “purposeful intentions, desires and goals drive our decisions in a linear cause-and-effect kind of way, our finding shows that our decisions are also influenced by neural noise within any given moment,” says the study co-author Jesse Bengson, a neuroscientist at the University of California, Davis. “This random firing, or noise, may even be the carrier upon which our consciousness rides, in the same way that radio static is used to carry a radio station.”

To understand more about conscious decision-making, Bengson’s team used electroencephalography (EEG) to measure the brain waves of 19 undergraduates as they looked at a screen and were cued to make a random decision about whether to look right or left.

When people made their decision, a characteristic signal registered that choice as a wave of electrical activity that spread across specific brain regions.

But in a fascinating twist, other electrical activity emanating from the back of the head predicted people’s decisions up to 800 milliseconds before the signature of conscious decision making emerged.

This brain activity wasn’t strictly a signal at all — it was “noise,” part of the brain’s omnipresent and seemingly random electrical firing. In fact, neuroscientists usually consider this background noise meaningless and subtract it when trying to figure out the brain response to a specific task, said Rick Addante, a neuroscientist at the University of Texas at Dallas who was not involved in the research.

In other words, some hidden signal in the background “noise” of the brain seemed to determine people’s conscious decisions before they made them.

“That’s what’s wild about it; it’s not all noise,” said Addante. “The question then becomes, what is it, and what is the information that it contains?”

“The state of the brain right before presentation of the cue determines whether you will attend to the left or to the right,” Bengson said. The experiment builds on a famous 1970s experiment by Benjamin Libet, a psychologist at UCSF who was later affiliated with the UC Davis Center for Neuroscience.

Libet also measured brain electrical activity immediately before a volunteer made a decision to press a switch in response to a visual signal. He found brain activity immediately before the volunteer reported deciding to press the switch.

The new results build on Libet’s finding, because they provide a model for how brain activity could precede decision, Bengson said. Additionally, Libet had to rely on when volunteers said they made their decision. In the new experiment, the random timing means that “we know people aren’t making the decision in advance,” Bengson said.

Libet’s experiment raised questions of free will — if our brain is preparing to act before we know we are going to act, how do we make a conscious decision to act?

Maybe free will is an illusion, but why does it feel so real?Though that’s still a mystery, one theory is that the belief in free will is an artifact that is necessary for human beings to get through life and survive.

The above story is based on materials provided by University of California – Davis  and

When Nisargadatta Maharaj was asked: Is there such a thing as free will? He answered: “Oh no. You are com­pelled to desire. In Hin­duism the very idea of free will is non-existent, so there is no word for it. Will is com­mit­ment, fix­a­tion, bondage.”

Related Dialogues

Please select the social network you want to share this page with:

We like you too :)
Science and Nonduality provides a forum where preeminent scientists, philosophers, teachers, artists and a large, international community gather to explore and advance the new paradigm emerging in spirituality, that is both grounded in cutting-edge science and consistent with the ancient wisdom of nonduality — the deep understanding of the interconnectedness of life.

2 Responses to “Does ‘free will’ Arise From Brain Noise?”

  1. June 20, 2014 at 9:22 am, David Chen said:

    I think you guys would find Stuart Hameroff’s work tremendously exciting. Anyway, here’s my take for what it’s worth. Free will is probably an illusion from an absolute, Godhead point of view from my studies and experience, but when you are having a human experience, you might as well allow yourself to act and think like you have free will, because the perception is inescapable much of the time.

    It is just like using your eyes and seeing an object. Your right brain cannot differentiate between that object and the space around it, but your left brain can. And so depending on your conscious state at the moment, you maybe perceiving an object or not depending on how utilitarian your brain deems one perception to be at the moment.

    Similarly, certain states of meditation/awareness would negate the perception of free will, and there maybe a fluctuation between throughout the day of a nondual practictioner between experiencing free will and not. Since ALL levels of experience are real to individual consciousnesses, perhaps it is best to say sometimes we have free will and sometimes we don’t.

Leave a Reply


Drugs and the Meaning of Life

Everything we do is for the purpose of altering consciousness. We form friendships so that we can feel certain emotions, like love, and avoid others, like loneliness. We eat specific foods to enjoy their fleeting presence…


The Foundation of World Peace: Rupert Spira

Rupert Spira makes the case for embracing one unique authority: the absolute knowledge of our own being. It is the only thing that all people have in common, the source of the peace and fulfillment for…

image description image description

Thanks To Our Sponsors